AllBestEssays.com - All Best Essays, Term Papers and Book Report
Search

Challenges with Citizens United Vs the Federal Election Commission

Essay by   •  November 19, 2015  •  Case Study  •  813 Words (4 Pages)  •  1,097 Views

Essay Preview: Challenges with Citizens United Vs the Federal Election Commission

Report this essay
Page 1 of 4

The challenge with Citizens United vs the Federal Election Commission (Library, 2010) is how to approach it. One can view it through the lens of ethics (Silver, 2014), through which it is a terrible decision. You could examine it from an empirical standpoint and, even given the limited time since it was decided, there’s already sufficient evidence to suggest it is (further) corrupting the electoral process in the United States (Spencer & Wood, 2014). One could also view it from a governance standpoint, examining whether it will increase or decrease the efficacy of boards over their corporations (Coates IV, 2012). Since the narrow definition of the role of the board it to increase corporate value, it is fairly straightforward to measure the effects of Citizen’s United and, according to Coates, it has been negative.

The lens through which I want to address Citizens United is the through the multidisciplinary lens of electoral and governance accountability. The question I’m trying to ask is this: does Citizens United increase or decrease the ability to hold our elected officials and our corporations accountable for their actions? I think, in spite of some commentators claims to the contrary (Bedford, 2010; Meyer, 2012), Citizens United exacerbated the already existing problem of what Monks calls “Drone Corporations,” (Monks, 1913) those in which ownership is too diffuse to apply any power over the Board and, consequently, instilling more power in the managerial class. By giving corporate executives even more unrestrained power to lobby, bribe, hire, and otherwise influence political decision-making, it allows them to continue to tip the scales away from workers and toward themselves, and takes away more of the influence of the electorate and puts it squarely in the hands of deep-pocketed business interests.

First, electoral accountability.  Citizens United essentially takes the previous legal fiction of corporate personhood and takes it as both a metaphysical and legal fact. The decision gives corporations the power to anonymously spend unlimited amounts of money influencing the electoral process based on the First Amendment’s free speech guarantees.  The managerial class have done a very effective job of increasing the amount of money that goes into their pockets and decreasing worker

 pay over the last 30 years (McCall & Percheski, 2010). Through their destruction of/decrease in participation in unions and conducting race-to-the-bottom labor arbitrage, the rich have become richer and poor, poorer. While money does not determine elections, in competitive, non-incumbency races, campaign contributions have a significant effect on a candidate’s chances of winning (Erikson & Palfrey, 1998) and it buys influence and access. Thus, with corporations having significantly more money than individuals, they will be able to significantly effect elections and elected representatives will feel most accountable to them for their continued support. Thus, Citizens United takes power away from actual people and decreases electoral accountability.

...

...

Download as:   txt (5.5 Kb)   pdf (98 Kb)   docx (10.3 Kb)  
Continue for 3 more pages »
Only available on AllBestEssays.com
Citation Generator

(2015, 11). Challenges with Citizens United Vs the Federal Election Commission. AllBestEssays.com. Retrieved 11, 2015, from https://www.allbestessays.com/essay/Challenges-with-Citizens-United-Vs-the-Federal-Election/60247.html

"Challenges with Citizens United Vs the Federal Election Commission" AllBestEssays.com. 11 2015. 2015. 11 2015 <https://www.allbestessays.com/essay/Challenges-with-Citizens-United-Vs-the-Federal-Election/60247.html>.

"Challenges with Citizens United Vs the Federal Election Commission." AllBestEssays.com. AllBestEssays.com, 11 2015. Web. 11 2015. <https://www.allbestessays.com/essay/Challenges-with-Citizens-United-Vs-the-Federal-Election/60247.html>.

"Challenges with Citizens United Vs the Federal Election Commission." AllBestEssays.com. 11, 2015. Accessed 11, 2015. https://www.allbestessays.com/essay/Challenges-with-Citizens-United-Vs-the-Federal-Election/60247.html.